Tag: student loans debt

OSAP BANKRUPTCY IS NOT AS SIMPLE AS YOU MIGHT THINK

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date May 29, 2019

OSAP bankruptcy Introduction

I have written before on the issue of the difficulty in discharging student loans through bankruptcy. Bankruptcy will certainly not release your student loans debt until you’ve been out of full or part-time studies for 7 years. It is also question and answer #8 in our TOP 20 PERSONAL BANKRUPTCY FAQS found on our main website. In Brandon’s Blog, I want to drill down into the issue of an OSAP bankruptcy.

What is OSAP?

The Ontario Student Assistance Program (OSAP) is a financial assistance program that can assist students in spending for college or university.

OSAP provides money via:

Grant: cash you do not need to repay
Loan: a loan you are required to pay off when you’re done college or university

OSAP can assist your spending for:

tuition
books and supplies/equipment
student fees billed by an institution
living expenditures
childcare

Amongst the various categories of people who are not eligible for OSAP, one is those people who have filed for either personal bankruptcy or a consumer proposal. As you might imagine, the rules surrounding OSAP bankruptcy are not simple. Let’s do some drilling down now!

Students that did not get student loans before the day they declared bankruptcy or filed a consumer proposal

If the student has been discharged from bankruptcy or fully completed a consumer proposal, she or he does not require to offer any type of supporting paperwork in order for their OSAP application to be reviewed.

If the student is an undischarged bankrupt or has not completed the consumer proposal, the student must supply a letter from their licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee) or consumer proposal administrator. The document must show the day the student filed for either bankruptcy or the consumer proposal and that these 2 matters have actually been or will be satisfied:

Ontario and Canada is not a creditor in the bankruptcy or consumer proposal as an outcome of monetary help provided via OSAP; and
no monetary help offered to the student via OSAP during the current OSAP year will be taken in the insolvency proceedings to pay back the creditors

Discharged and the student is not presently enrolled in studies

If the student is discharged from bankruptcy or has successfully completed a consumer proposal, his/her OSAP application will not be decided upon until the student gives evidence that they have no amount owing on any student loans.

Alternatively, if applicable, the student can show that he/she received relief in their bankruptcy by way of a court order stating that section 178(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA) no longer applies to the student loans.

In this situation, the student needs to supply:

evidence that an order of discharge or full completion of the consumer proposal has been achieved and that 3 years have expired since that date
a copy of the notice of bankruptcy/consumer proposal
letter from the student’s bank and/or the National Student Loans Service Centre confirming there is no outstanding balance
any relevant court order

Discharged and continuing a program of study

Alternatively, if applicable, the student can show that he/she received relief in their bankruptcy by way of a court order stating that section 178(1)(g) of the BIA no longer applies to the student loans.

In this situation, the student needs to prove that he/she meets all of the following criteria:

at the time the student declared bankruptcy or filed the consumer proposal, they were enrolled in an accepted program of study at an accepted school and taking the minimum called for course load
the student remains in the same accepted program they were in on the date of bankruptcy/consumer proposal filing date
the student has not had a break in studies longer than 6 months since the date of bankruptcy/consumer proposal filing date
it has not been greater than 3 fiscal years since the date of bankruptcy/consumer proposal filing date

In this situation, the student needs to supply:

evidence that an order of discharge or full completion of the consumer proposal has been achieved and that 3 years have expired since that date
a copy of the notice of bankruptcy/consumer proposal
letter from the student’s bank and/or the National Student Loans Service Centre confirming there is no outstanding balance
any relevant court order
letter from the student’s Financial Aid Office verifying that the program of study in which the student was registered at the time of the bankruptcy/consumer proposal filing, is the same as the program the student is now applying for

Undischarged bankrupt or has not yet fully completed the consumer proposal

If the student is an undischarged bankrupt or has not successfully completed a consumer proposal, the processing of the student’s OSAP application will not be completed until the student gives evidence that they have no amount owing on any student loans.

In this situation, the student needs to prove that he/she meets all of the following criteria:

at the time the student declared bankruptcy or filed the consumer proposal, they were enrolled in an accepted program of study at an accepted school and taking the minimum called for course load
the student remains in the same accepted program the were in on the date of bankruptcy/consumer proposal filing date
the student has not had a break in studies longer than 6 months since the date of bankruptcy/consumer proposal filing date
it has not been greater than 3 fiscal years since the date of bankruptcy/consumer proposal filing date

In this situation, the student needs to supply a letter from their licensed insolvency trustee or consumer proposal administrator. The document must show the day the student filed for either bankruptcy or the consumer proposal and that these 2 matters have actually been or will be satisfied:

Ontario and Canada is not a creditor in the bankruptcy or consumer proposal as an outcome of monetary help provided via OSAP; and
no monetary help offered to the student via OSAP during the current OSAP year will be taken in the insolvency proceedings to pay back the creditors

The student will also need to supply a:

letter from the student’s bank and/or the National Student Loans Service Centre confirming there is no outstanding balance
any relevant court order
letter from the student’s Financial Aid Office verifying that the program of study in which the student was registered at the time of the bankruptcy/consumer proposal filing, is the same as the program the student is now applying for

Summary

I hope you now understand that the whole area of OSAP bankruptcy and student loans in either a bankruptcy or consumer proposal is not as simple as you might have originally thought. This is especially the case if the student is continuing his or her studies.

Do you have too much debt? Are you in financial distress? Do you not have adequate funds to pay your financial obligations as they come due?

If so, call the Ira Smith Team today. We have decades and generations of experience assisting people looking for financial restructuring, a debt settlement plan and to AVOID bankruptcy.

As a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee), we are the only professionals accredited, acknowledged and supervised by the federal government to provide insolvency advice and to implement approaches to help you remain out of personal bankruptcy while eliminating your debts. A consumer proposal is a government approved debt settlement plan to do that. We will help you decide on what is best for you between a consumer proposal vs bankruptcy.

Call the Ira Smith Team today so you can eliminate the stress, anxiety, and pain from your life that your financial problems have caused. With the one-of-a-kind roadmap, we develop just for you, we will immediately return you right into a healthy and balanced problem-free life.

You can have a no-cost analysis so we can help you fix your troubles. Call the Ira Smith Team today. This will allow you to go back to a new healthy and balanced life, Starting Over Starting Now.

Tags bankrupt, Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, bankruptcy trustee, BIA, Consumer Proposal, consumer proposal administrator, date of bankruptcy, discharged from bankruptcy, filing date, Ira Smith Trustee, licensed insolvency trustee, national student loans service centre, osap, osap bankruptcy, student loan, student loan debt, student loans, student loans debt, undischarged bankrupt

Brandon Blog Post

REPAYMENT OF STUDENT LOANS CANADA: STUDENTS’ #1 WORRY-STUDENT LOANS DEBT

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date July 9, 2018

August 30, 2018 – NEW BONUS VIDEO AT THE BOTTOM OF THIS BLOG

Introduction

Although I can’t now fathom a world without the Internet, there are some reasons to wax nostalgic about the good old days. Most notably, many families lived nicely on one income and people retired from their jobs with a defined pension plan. They did not have to worry about repayment of student loans Canada. It was commonplace for students to put themselves through college working summers and weekends during the school year.

There is a new reality

Those days are gone! Two incomes are now an absolute necessity for most families and defined pensions have all but disappeared. To pay for university, even with working summers and weekends, students are saddled with enormous loans. In the 2015-16 school year, 497,000 students enrolled in the Canada Student Loans Program.

Students #1 worry

Dan Allan, Director of the Student Budget Consultation Program, states:

“While students are concerned about unemployment after school, their biggest worry is about their university debt and the cost of education being a huge hurdle going forward”

Why is there so much student loans debt?

Government funding dropped from over 77% in 1992 to less than 55% in 2012. To make up the difference, post-secondary institutions turned to students. Tuition fees began to rise – 115% between 1980 and 1995 (Glenn Burley, Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives)
By 2016-17, the average Canadian university tuition was about 40% higher than it had been in 2006. (Fred Lum/Globe and Mail)
Tuition fees increased by 3.1% per cent for undergraduate programs in the 2017-18 academic years (Statistics Canada)
The average tuition cost for a Canadian university — before the cost of books, travel and supplies — is $6,500 per year (Statistics Canada)
The average amount owing for both bachelor and master’s graduates is $26,000 and $41,100 for doctorate graduates (Statistics Canada)

What happens when students can’t repay their student loans?

According to Dan Allan, the current Liberal government wrote off $200 million dollars in outstanding student loans on which it will never be able to collect. This is the third time in the past four years that the government has had to write off outstanding loans for reasons that include bankruptcy. There is a six-year legal limit on collection and debtors who can no longer be found. This results in direct student loans loan forgiveness.

How can young people get ahead when student loans are holding them back? As a society, we must increase our investment in education. Instead of the government writing off hundreds of millions of dollars in uncollectable student loan debt, wouldn’t that money be better spent on funding education?

Repayment of student loans Canada: What to do if you have too much debt

You can certainly contact Canada student loans to find out about their program for those having trouble repaying their student loan debt. If you’re a graduate with student loan debt that you can’t repay, and you were not able to work out an arrangement with Canada student loans then you are in a student loans debt crisis. If you are struggling with student loan debt, or debt for any other reason, you need professional help and you need it now. We understand your pain points and we know how to relieve you of the stress and pain.

The Ira Smith Trustee Team can help you manage your debt and set you on a path to debt free living Starting Over, Starting Now. We’re only a phone call away.

Tags average tuition, Bankruptcy, canada student loans contact, canada student loans program, defined pension plan, direct student loans loan forgiveness, Director of the Student Budget Consultation Program, Ira Smith Trustee, outstanding student loans, repayment of student loans canada, student loan debt, student loans, student loans debt, student loans debt crisis, tuition fees, university tuition

Brandon Blog Post

#VIDEO-STUDENT DEBT: HOW TUITION COSTS AND DEBT NEGATIVELY AFFECTS US#

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date September 7, 2016

STUDENT DEBT: HOW TUITION COSTS AND DEBT NEGATIVELY AFFECTS US

Student debt: The times have changed already!

Times have changed so much for university graduates and unfortunately, student debt counselling has not kept pace with today’s reality. Students graduate with various student loans and varying amounts of debt. The theory is that graduates will get a well-paying job in their chosen field upon graduation, allowing them to work and to repay their student loan debt.

Our previous student debt counselling and student loans blogs and vlogs

Student loan debt is such a serious issue that we’ve written a series of blogs and vlogs on the subject:

Student debt: What can today’s graduates expect?

However, in today’s world, their job searching may result in them not getting immediately into their field at the salary they anticipated. It may be the case that graduates may have to do a couple of different part-time jobs, may start being underemployed and in some cases, starting out interning and being in their chosen field but not being paid at all. This will put immense pressure on the new graduate who needs to start repaying debt in addition to normal living expenses.

Student debt: How much of a problem is it really?

Post-secondary education is effectively a need to succeed in today’s labour market. Unfortunately, while the demand for education has increased, public funding has failed to keep up.

According to the Canadian Federation of Students, public funding shortfalls have resulted in a significant growth of costs that students must now bear, namely in the form of high tuition fees. From 1990 to 2014, national average tuition fees have seen an inflation-adjusted increase of over 155%. In Ontario, tuition fees have increased over 180%.

They also state that students who receive funding through the Canada Student Loans Program (CSLP) are graduating with an average student loan debt of $28,495. This is only student loan debt and doesn’t include any other borrowings for living expenses if the student is living away from home. The impact of Canada student loan debt is that today’s students are the most indebted generation in Canadian history. They can certainly use student debt counselling.

Student debt: We need more than just counselling

Although financial counselling should begin at home at a very young age, and be reinforced through teachings at the high school level, more than debt management lessons are required. We need our provincial and federal governments to take the lead. There needs to be an easing of the burden on graduates. Graduates with high student loan debt show signs of poor mental health in early adulthood. This certainly must impact their work performance and is not healthy for Canadian society.

Our governments need to look seriously at the public funding model for post-secondary school education. It is not helping Canadians to allow them to incur high student debt for fields of study where the job prospects, and the prospect of being able to repay the loans, are dim. It does not help Canadian graduates to have them under so much pressure to repay loans after graduation – perhaps there needs to be federal government intervention to ease the repayment program. In this way graduates can have the necessary time to get their employment, contribute to Canadian society, pay income taxes AND repay student loans.

These are just but a few simple ideas. I am sure that you can come up with many more and I would love to hear about them.

Are you in need of student debt counselling or credit or debt counselling in general?

No matter the cause of your serious debt issues, The Ira Smith Team is here to help. Debt is not insurmountable; there are always options. With proper counselling, immediate action and a solid plan, we can help get your life back on track Starting Over, Starting Now. Our trustees are also certified in credit counselling. Give us a call today.

THIS VLOG WAS INSPIRED IN PART BY OUR eBOOK – PERSONAL BANKRUPTCY CANADA: Not because you are a dummy, because you need to get your life back on track

Tags average student loan debt, canada student loans program, canadian federation of students, CSLP, debt counselling, debt management lessons, financial counselling, Ira Smith Trustee, student debt, student debt counselling, student loan debt, student loans debt

Brandon Blog Post

STUDENT LOANS DEBT: WILL BANKRUPTCY ELIMINATE IT IF YOU ARE NOT THE STUDENT?

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date April 25, 2016

An interesting American case about student loans debt

Student loans debt is nearly impossible to get rid of in bankruptcy. A case winding its way through the US court system has piqued our intellectual interest. A father, who is a discharged bankrupt, is taking the lender who HE borrowed funds from for his child’s education to Court. The lender is continuing to pursue collection efforts against the father on the basis that the provisions of the Bankruptcy Reform Act of 1978, as amended, codified in Title 11 of the United States Code and commonly called the “Bankruptcy Code” (“Code”), does not release the father from what is in reality student loans debt. The father is taking the lender to Court for a ruling that by virtue of his discharge, he is released from that debt like all his other debts. It has raised the question whether the same student loans debt rules should apply in that case.

The Canadian perspective

We are not qualified to express any opinion on the US legal case before the US Court, but we are qualified to discuss the issue from the Canadian perspective. We started thinking whether this same situation could arise in Canada for student loans.

Last week we discussed student debt bankruptcy from the perspective of the student. Previously, we have written blogs and created a vlog about student loan debt, including:

So this week, we’re discussing student loan debt and bankruptcy from a very different and interesting angle. Could a Canadian lender take the position against a Canadian parent borrower who on the loan application described the purpose of the loans for the funding of his or her child’s Canadian post-secondary education, that the loans qualify as student loans under the applicable Canadian statutes, including, the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA). Stated otherwise, are such loans the same as student loans under Canadian law and can bankruptcy cut such loans if you’re not the student?

Are student loans necessary?

Many young Canadians need student loans to get a post-secondary education. To qualify as Canadian student loan debt, the loans must be issued under a specific Canadian student loan statute: the (i) Canada Student Loans Act; (ii) Canada Student Financial Assistance Act; (iii) Apprentice Loans Act; or (iv) any enactment of a province that provides for loans or guarantees of loans to students.

All students need financial help to be full-time university students. The only real places that such assistance can come from is either the parents, if they are willing and able to do so, student loans, or both. Many Canadian parents pay a hefty part of students’ tuition fees, even if it means sacrificing their financial stability, to help their children avoid a post-graduation life burdened by tens of thousands of dollars of student debt. Others may wish to, but they cannot afford to do so.

So are student loans and the resultant debt necessary? In most cases, yes.

Can a parent co-sign for or guarantee their child’s student loans?

The short answer is no. As I have already stated, to qualify as a student loan, the loan has to be made under the provisions of one of the Federal loan statutes mentioned above, or any such similar Provincial legislation. Nowhere in those student loans statutes is there a place for either a guarantor or cosigner. In fact, the Federal statutes all have similar language stating that upon the death of the borrower, the Federal government will repay the outstanding part of the loan. In addition to there not being any sections that allow for a guarantor or cosigner, the specific section dealing with the death of the borrower does not limit the government’s guarantee by using words like “….and if the lender is unable to collect in full from any guarantor or cosigner”. The reason is simple, student loans cannot be guaranteed or otherwise borrowed by anyone other than the student.

Will bankruptcy eliminate student loans debt?

Student loans are nearly impossible to get rid of in bankruptcy. Section 178(1) of the BIA states:

“(g) any debt or obligation in respect of a loan made under the Canada Student Loans Act, the Canada Student Financial Assistance Act or any enactment of a province that provides for loans or guarantees of loans to students where the date of bankruptcy of the bankrupt occurred:

(i) before the date on which the bankrupt ceased to be a full- or part-time student, as the case may be, under the applicable Act or enactment, or

(ii) within seven years after the date on which the bankrupt ceased to be a full- or part-time student;

(g.1) any debt or obligation in respect of a loan made under the Apprentice Loans Act where the date of bankruptcy of the bankrupt occurred

(i) before the date on which the bankrupt ceased, under that Act, to be an eligible apprentice within the meaning of that Act, or

(ii) within seven years after the date on which the bankrupt ceased to be an eligible apprentice;”

So if you’re a student, bankruptcy will only end student loans if you’ve ceased to be a full or part-time student for more than seven years and either declare personal bankruptcy or make a debt proposal to your creditors, most likely through a consumer proposal. The only other option is to attempt to seek from the Court relief because of undue hardship, but this is very difficult, if not impossible.

What is required to meet the burden of undue hardship?

If the Court is satisfied that you meet the two-pronged test, you’ll be discharged from your student loans obligations in bankruptcy only if the :

acted in good faith in connection with your obligation to repay your student loan debt; and (emphasis added)
have experienced, and will continue to experience, financial difficulty that will prevent you from repaying this debt

It’s then up to the bankruptcy court to decide whether they forgive your loans, either in full or in part. One of the difficulties in trying to prove undue hardship is that there is no clear definition for what makes up hardship; each bankruptcy court across Canada may use a slightly different interpretation. The only thing that’s clear is that you must prove that having to continue to pay the student loans after bankruptcy would be a financial hardship for you. If you try this route, the Court will look at ALL of your income and expenses.

The Court may decide you are not trying hard enough, or, may look at things like your small car you use to get to work, which you purchased used (instead of taking public transit), your cell phone and your internet expenses, and decide that these are luxuries you do not need. If you are a smoker, the Court may very well decide that if you were not addicted to tobacco, you could start to repay some part of your student loans.

If you think my examples are picayune or silly, just look up the case of Fournier (Re), 2009 CanLII 31606 (ON SC).

Will bankruptcy eliminate student loan debt if you are not the student?

I don’t know what the eventual disposition of the US case which I mentioned at the beginning of this blog will be, but based on all the above, in my view in the Canadian context, a parent, relative or friend cannot guarantee, cosign or borrow for a loan that qualifies as a Canadian student loan. If you borrow to fund your child’s education, then you are borrowing under an ordinary commercial transaction and the applicable student loan sections of the BIA do not apply.

So if you have borrowed for this purpose, only the normal provisions of the BIA apply, and you will get a discharge from that and your other debts upon your discharge from bankruptcy. However, if you pledged any of your assets in support of such borrowings, such as your home, the lender does have the right to enforce its security against such assets if you cannot repay, whether you are bankrupt or not.

What should you do if you have too much debt?

If you’re drowning because of your finances, we know we can help you. Although many people believe that bankruptcy is the only way of out serious debt, that’s not always the case. Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc.can discuss other bankruptcy alternatives with you which include credit counselling, debt consolidation and consumer proposals.

If we get to see you early enough, at the first sign of trouble, you can use and carry out one of the bankruptcy alternatives, to free you from the burden of your financial challenges to go on to be a productive, contributing member of society and not be plagued by debt problems.

Bankruptcy law is very complicated and requires the expertise of a professional licensed insolvency trustee. Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is here to help. With a cumulative 50+ years of experience dealing with diverse issues and complex files, we can get you back on your feet Starting Over, Starting Now. We can help. Call us today.

People consider us bankruptcy experts because we wrote the eBook which is sold on Amazon.ca, explaining the Canadian personal insolvency and bankruptcy system, specifically directed to the person stressed out with too much debt.